The Czech Green Party has officially submitted its comments to the Ministry of the Environment regarding the proposed Děčín navigation weir. The party is demanding that the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) be supplemented with reliable climate projections and rigorous proof of overriding public interest. The current notification relies on outdated data from several years ago, ignoring the steady, long-term decline in the Elbe’s water levels observed over the past 45 years.
“The question is not whether we are for or against inland shipping. It is about whether this project is realistic, thought through in a broader context, and whether it will genuinely improve navigation conditions over its lifespan,” said Miroslav Štross, spokesperson for the Greens.
A Project Rooted in the Past Clashes with Climate Reality
The proposed infrastructure draws on the legacy of the Czechoslovak Elbe Navigation company, which employed nearly 4,000 people in the 1980s. However, the sector’s decline following economic transformation and the end of coal transport in 1996 cannot be blamed solely on fluctuating water levels. Despite the river’s worsening water scarcity, the project’s blueprint still anticipates up to 11,600 vessels per year.
Several major flaws undermine the technical dossier:
- Contradictory hydrological forecasts: The notice fails to specify the reference water flow used to design the weir. The developer’s own documents project that by 2050, the minimum flow rate (exceeded 95% of the year in Ústí nad Labem) will drop to 93 m³/s—well below the 117 m³/s required to achieve the targeted 1.40-meter draft.
- Uncertainty over water reserves: The study omits how frequently water will need to be released from upstream dams to maintain river levels. Yet just this past September, severe drought forced the Vltava River Basin authority to tap into the strategic reserve of the Slapy Dam for the very first time in history.
- A cross-border bottleneck: While the weir promises a 1.40-meter draft, the Czech-German agreement only guarantees a 1.40-meter channel depth on the German side—translating to an actual usable draft of just 1 to 1.25 meters. A vessel loaded to full capacity in Děčín would run aground as soon as it crossed the border.
- Disputed economic figures: Freight projections (4.7 million tons annually) rely on outdated studies from 2015 and 2016, whose findings were previously deemed uncredible by the Czech Supreme Audit Office. Meanwhile, the climate study estimates that greenhouse gas emissions would drop by a mere 1% to 1.6%.
An Irreversible Threat to European Biodiversity
Ecologically, the infrastructure would inflict permanent damage. All relevant authorities—including the Bohemian Switzerland National Park Administration and the Nature Conservation Agency (AOPK)—agree that a significant negative impact on the European Natura 2000 network cannot be ruled out. Protected sites in Porta Bohemica and the Elbe Valley would suffer the irreplaceable loss of muddy riverbanks as well as alluvial forests, which are classified as priority habitats.
Under European and national law, such a project can only be approved if no environmentally friendlier alternative exists, strict compensatory measures are enforced, and an overriding public interest is credibly proven—a process that typically requires the approval of the European Commission.
Demanding Transparency Amid a Rushed Timeline
“Public interest cannot simply be declared; it must be credibly demonstrated,” insists Miroslav Štross. The Greens are calling for comprehensive flow modeling across the structure’s entire lifespan and a realistic assessment of actual freight demand.
This warning comes after Environment Minister Igor Červený (of the Motoristé sobě party) announced this summer that construction would begin in 2029—before the necessary scientific data is even available. For environmentalists, the red line is clear: if the developer fails to prove the urgent public interest of destroying the last natural stretch of the Czech Elbe, the project must be halted entirely.













